Critical Analysis of the Quranic Interpretive and Narrative Approach of Madelung on the Succession of the Holy Prophet

Document Type : Original Article

Authors

1 PhD in Islamic History, Bagheral Uloom University (peace be upon him), Researcher at Imam Athar Institute (peace be upon him)

2 PhD in Quran and Orientalists, Al-Mustafa International University, Qom, Iran

Abstract

The issue of the succession of the Holy Prophet is one of the most important and distinguishing aspects of Shiite Islam compared to other Islamic sects. This paper employs a descriptive-analytical method with a critical approach to examine the Quranic approach of Wilferd Madelung on the issue of the succession of the Holy Prophet (with a focus on the interpretive and narrative sources of both sects). Madelung initiated this movement in his book “Succession to Mohammad,” which was published in 1997 and soon became a significant reference in this discussion. In the introduction to his book titled “Familial Relationships and Prophetic Families in the Quran,” he extensively examines the role and importance of the Prophet's progeny in confirming, establishing, and continuing their mission and guidance. He demonstrates that, according to the Quran, the successors of the prophets are chosen from among their families and appointed by them, and the Holy Prophet had no intention other than this. Despite the relatively recent and delayed studies in Shi'a studies and Shi'a research activities, addressing the issue of Imamate (leadership) is of greater necessity compared to other raised issues. The study of opinions and views of interpreters from both sects regarding the interpretation of the verse of “Wilayah” (guardianship) indicates that they generally have two main perspectives based on Verse 55 of Surah Al-Ma'idah: 1. Most Sunni interpreters understand the term “wali” in the verse to mean friend and supporter, and based on this, they consider guardianship in the verse as absolute and inclusive of all believers. 2. Shi'a scholars do not merely understand the term “wali” to mean love and support, and they perceive such a meaning to conflict with other verses. They believe that in addition to love, this term encompasses social and political authority, and support is one of its outcomes. Based on the meaning of “wali” in the verse and the excessive (mutawatir) narrations, which attribute the revelation of the verse to the guardianship of Imam Ali, Shi'a interpreters consider the noble verse as Quranic evidence of the guardianship and Imamate of Imam Ali.

Keywords

References

  1. Translation of the Holy Quran by Dr. Mohammad Ali Rezaei Isfahani.
  2. Abu al-Abbas, Ahmad bin Ibrahim, Al-Masabih (The Lanterns), N.p., Imam Zaid bin Ali Foundation, n.d.
  3. Abu al-Hassan Ali bin Mohammad, Al-Ahkam al-Sultaniyyah (The Laws of Governance), al-Mawardi, N.p., Islamic Information Office, 1406 AH.
  4. Akhtab Khwarazm, Mawffaq bin Ahmad, Al-Manaqib (The Virtues), Edited by Malik Mahmoudi, Qom: Islamic Publications Office, n.d.
  5. Amini Najafi, Mohammad, Sir-i Dar al-Ghadir (A Glipmse at al-Ghadir), Qom: Nashr -e- Mowallif, 1370 SH / 1991 CE.
  6. Amini, Abdul Hossein, Al-Ghadir fi al-Kitab wa al-Sunnah wa al-Adab (Al-Ghadir in the Book, Sunnah, and Literature), 2nd Edition, Tehran: Dar al-Kutub al-Islamiyyah, 1366 SH / 1987 CE.
  7. Ash'ari, Abu al-Hassan Ali bin Ismail, Maqalat al-Islamiyyin (The Articles of the Muslims), N.p., Islamic Publications, 1400 AH.
  8. Bahrani, Seyyed Hashim, Ghayat al-Maram wa Hujjat al-Khisam fi Ta'ayin al-Imam min Tariq al-Khass wa al-A'am (The Ultimate Goal and Convincing Argument in Determining the Imam through the Specific and General Ways), Beirut: Arab History Institution, 1422 AH.
  9. Baqillani, Abu Bakr, Tamhid al-Awail wa Talkhis al-Dalail (Preparation of the Beginners and Summarization of the Proofs), 2nd Edition, Beirut, Lebanon: Cultural Books Institution, 1414 AH.
  10. Campbell, Robert A., Leadership succession in early Islam‌‌‌‌: Exploring the nature and role of historical precedents, The Leadership Quarterly 19 (2008) 426–438.
  11. Catherine Rockwell, “Review of The Succession to Mohammad‌‌‌‌: A Study of the Early Caliphate”, MELA Notes, No. 65/66 (Fall 1997 -Spring 1998), pp. 83-84.
  12. Daftari, Farhad‌‌‌‌: A History of Shi’i Islam, The Institute of Ismaili Studies; London, 2013.
  13. Daniel, Elton L., “Review of The Succession to Mohammad‌‌‌‌: A Study of the Early Caliphate”, Middle East Journal, Vol. 52, No. 3 (Summer, 1998), pp. 471-472.
  14. Fakhr al-Din Razi, Abu Abdullah Mohammad bin Umar, Mafatih al-Ghayb (Keys to the Unseen World), Beirut: Dar Ihya al-Turath al-Arabi, 3rd Edition, 1420 AH.
  15. Farahidi, Abdul Rahman Khalil bin Ahmad, Kitab al-Ayn (The Book of Essence), N.p., Dar al-Hijrah Institute, 1409 AH.
  16. Goldziher‌‌‌‌, Beitrage zue literaturgeschichte der Shi’a und der sunnitischen Poemik, Vienna, 1874.
  17. Halm, Heinz‌‌‌‌: Shi'ism, Edinburgh, 1991.
  18. Haskani, Abdullah bin Ahmad, Shawahid al-Tanzil li-Qawa'id al-Tafdil (The Evidences of Revelation for the Principles of Precedence), Tehran: Organization of Printing and Publishing, Ministry of Islamic Guidance, 1411 AH.
  19. Heinzelman, Shia, Translation: Mohammad Taqi Akbari, Qom: Adyan, 1385 SH / 2006 CE.
  20. Hilli, Hassan bin Youssef, Nahj al-Haqq wa Kashf al-Sidq (The Path of Truth and Unveiling of the Sincerity), Qom: Dar al-Hijrah Foundation, 1407 AH.
  21. Ibn Atiyyah Andalusi, Abdul Haq, Al-Muharrar al-Wajiz fi Tafsir al-Kitab al-Aziz (The Concise Elucidation in the Interpretation of the Noble Book), Beirut: Dar al-Kutub al-Ilmiyyah, 1422 AH.
  22. Ibn Babawayh, Mohammad bin Ali, Al-Khisal (The Comprehensive Book of Virtuous Traits), Qom: Jame'e Mudarrisin, 1362 SH / 1983 CE.
  23. Ibn Faris, Ahmad, Maqayis al-Lughah (Dictionary of the Measurements of the Arabic Language), Edited by Haroon Abdul Salam Mohammad, Qom: Islamic Preaching Office Publications, 1404 AH.
  24. Ibn Kathir Dimashqi, Ismail bin Amr, Tafsir al-Quran al-Azim (The Exegesis of Gracious Quran (Tafsir Ibn Kathir)), Beirut: Dar al-Kutub al-Ilmiyyah, Mohammad Ali Baydoun Publications, 1419 AH.
  25. Ibn Shahr Ashub, Mohammad bin Ali, Mutashabih al-Quran wa Mukhtalifuh (Ambiguity and Different Verses of the Quran), Qom: Bidar, 1410 AH.
  26. Ibn Taymiyyah, Ahmad bin Abdul-Halim, Minhaj al-Sunnah al-Nabawiyyah (The Way of the Prophetic Sunnah), Edited by Mohammad Rashad Salim, Qurtuba Foundation, 1406 AH.
  27. Ja'fari, Mohammad Reza; Ha'iri, Seyyed Hossein, “An Essay on the Meaning of the Term Wali,” Imamate Studies Quarterly, Issue 1, 1390 SH / 2011 CE.
  28. Jassas, Ahmad bin Ali, Ahkam al-Quran (Rulings of the Quran), Beirut: Dar Ihya al-Turath al-Arabi, 1405 AH.
  29. Javadi Amoli, Abdullah, Thematic Interpretation of the Holy Quran (Revelation and Prophethood in the Quran), Qom: Nasr -e- Isra, 1384 SH / 2005 CE.
  30. Jurjani, Mir Seyyed Sharif Ali bin Mohammad, Sharh al-Mawaqif (Explanation of Mawaqif), 2nd Edition, Beirut: Dar al-Kutub al-Ilmiyyah, 1433 AH.
  31. Juwayni, Al-Haramayn, Abdul Malik, Al-Irsyad fi al-Kalam (Guidance in Discourse/ Theology), Edited by Asa’d Tamim, 3rd Edition, Beirut: Cultural Books Institution, 1416 AH.
  32. Juwayni, Ibrahim bin Mohammad, Fara'id al-Samtayn (Unique Pearls), Beirut: Al-Mahmoudi Institution, 1398 AH.
  33. Kennedy, Hugh, “Review of The Succession to Mohammad‌‌‌‌: A Study of the Early Caliphate”, Journal of the Royal Asiatic Society, Third Series, Vol. 8, No. 1 (Apr. 1998), pp. 88-89.
  34. Kohlberg, Etan, Belief and Law in Imami Shi’ism (Collected Studies series), Gower Publishing, 1991.
  35. Kulayni, Mohammad bin Ya'qub, Al-Kafi (The Sufficient), 4th Edition, Tehran: Dar al-Kutub al-Islamiyyah, 1407 AH.
  36. Lahiji, Fayyaz, Gohar -e- Murad (The Desired Gem), Tehran: Sayeh Publishing, 1383 SH / 2004 CE.
  37. Lalani, Arzina R., Early Shi’i Thought; The Teaching of Imam Mohammad al-Baqir, I.B. Tauriss Publication, 2000.
  38. Lindsay, James E., “Review of The Succession to Mohammad‌‌‌‌: A Study of the Early Caliphate”, Middle East Studies Association Bulletin, Vol. 31, No. 2 (December 1997), pp. 166-167.
  39. Madelung, Wilferd, The Succession to Mohammad, Cambridge University Press, 1997
  40. Mattson, Ingrid, “Review of The Succession to Mohammad‌‌‌‌: A Study of the Early Caliphate”, The Journal of Religion. Vol. 78, No. 2 (1998), pp. 321-322.
  41. Milani, Seyyed Ali, Al-Usul al-Ammah li Masa'il al-Imamah (The General Principles of Imamate Issues), Qom: Haqa'iq Publishing, 1435 AH.
  42. Momen, Moojan‌‌‌‌, An Introduction to Shi’i Islam, Yale University Press; U.S.; 1985.
  43. Morony, Michael G., “Review of The Succession to Mohammad‌‌‌‌: A Study of the Early Caliphate”, Journal of Near Eastern Studies, Vol. 59, No. 2 (Apr., 2000), pp. 153-156.
  44. Mufid, Mohammad bin Mohammad, Tafsir al-Quran al-Majid (Exegesis of the Noble Quran), Qom: Center for the Publication of Islamic Preaching Office, 1414 AH.
  45. Muslim bin al-Hajjaj al-Qushayri, Abu al-Hossein, Sahih Muslim, Edited by Mohammad Fuad Abdul Baqi, Beirut: Dar Ihya al-Turath al-Arabi, n.d.
  46. Najjarzadegan, Fathollah, Barrasi Tatbiqi Ayat -e- Wilayah dar Didgah -e- Faraqayn (Investigation of the Application of Verses on Guardianship in the View of the Two Sects), Qom: Hawzah and University Research Institute, Tehran: SAMT Publications, 1391 SH / 2012 CE.
  47. Newman, Andrew J., “Review of The Succession to Mohammad‌‌‌‌: A Study of the Early Caliphate”, Iranian Studies, Vol. 32, No. 3 (Summer, 1999), pp. 403-405.
  48. Newman, Andrew J., The Formative Period of Twelver Shi'ism, Routledge, 2001.
  49. Qadi Abd al-Jabbar, Sharh al-Usul al-Khamsah (Explanation of the Five Principles), Beirut: Dar Ihya al-Turath al-Arabi, 1422 AH.
  50. Qunduzi Hanafi, Sheikh Sulayman, Yanabi' al-Mawaddah (Springs of Affection), Beirut: Mo'assasah al-A'lami, 1418 AH.
  51. Qurtubi, Mohammad, Al-Jami' li Ahkam al-Quran (The Comprehensive Collection of Quranic Rulings), Tehran: Naser Khosrow Publications, 1364 SH / 1985 CE.
  52. Raghib Isfahani, Hossein bin Mohammad, Mufradat Alfaz al-Quran (Vocabulary of the Words of the Quran), Lebanon - Syria: Dar al-Ilm - Dar al-Shamiyyah, 1412 AH.
  53. Rawandi, Qutb al-Din, Fiqh al-Quran fi Sharh Ayat al-Ahkam (Jurisprudence of the Quran in Explaining the Verses of Rulings), Qom: Ayatollah Mara’shi Najafi Library, 1405 AH.
  54. Razi, Abu Al-Fatuh, Tafsir Rooh al-Jinan (Exegesis of the Spirit of Heavens), Qom: Ayatollah Mara’shi Library Publications, 1408 AH.
  55. Robert Gleave, Recent Research into the History of Early Shi’ism, History Compass, 7/6 (2009).
  56. Sa'd al-Din, Taftazani, Sharh al-Maqasid (Commentary on Maqasid), Edited and Researched by Abd al-Rahman U’mairah, Qom: Sharif al-Radhi Publications, 1370 SH / 1991 CE.
  57. Sahib bin I’bad, Ismail bin I’bad, Al-Muhit fi al-Lughah (The Comprehensive in Language), Beirut: A’lam al-Kitab, 1414 AH.
  58. Shahristani, Mohammad bin Abdul Karim, Milal wa Nihal (Religious Sects and Creeds), Qom: Sharif al-Radhi, 1364 SH / 1985 CE.
  59. Sharon, Moshe, “The Development of The Debate Around The Legitimacy of Authority in Early Islam”, Jerusalem Studies in Arabic and Islam 5.2 (1984)‌‌‌‌: 121-141.
  60. Sobhi Saleh, Ulum al-Hadith wa Mustalahuh (The Sciences of Hadith and Its Terminology), 5th Edition, Qom: Islamic Book House, 1363 SH / 1984 CE.
  61. Suyuti, Jalal al-Din, Al-Durr al-Munthur fi Tafsir al-Mathur (The Scattered Pearls in the Commentary of the Quran), Qom: Ayatollah Mara’shi Najafi Library, 1404 AH.
  62. Tabari, Abu Jafar Mohammad bin Jarir, Jami’ al-Bayan fi Tafsir al-Quran (The Comprehensive Explanation in the Interpretation of the Quran), Beirut: Dar al-Ma'rifah, 1412 AH.
  63. Tabari, Ibn Jarir Rustam, Dalail al-Imamah (Proofs of Imamate), Qom: Bi’tha'at, n.d.
  64. Tabarsi, Fazl bin Hassan, Majma al-Bayan fi Tafsir al-Quran (The Compilation of Elucidation in the Interpretation of the Quran), Translation: A Group of Translators, Qom: Farahani Publishing, 1360 SH / 1981 CE.
  65. Tabatabai, Mohammad Hossein, Al-Mizan fi Tafsir al-Quran (The Balance in the Interpretation of the Quran), 5th Edition, Qom: Islamic Publications Office of the Qom Seminary Teachers' Society, 1417 AH.
  66. Tabatabai, Mohammad Hossein, Shia dar Islam (Shiism in Islam), Qom: Islamic Publication Center, 1378 SH / 1999 CE.
  67. Takim, Liyakat, Heirs of the Prophet‌‌‌‌: Charisma and Religious Authority in Shi’ite Islam, Albany, NY‌‌‌‌: State University of New York Press, 2006.
  68. Tha'labi Nishapuri, Abu Ishaq Ahmad bin Ibrahim, Al-Kashf wa al-Bayan an Tafsir al-Quran (Discovery and Explanation of the Interpretation of the Quran), Beirut: Dar Ihya al-Turath al-Arabi, 1422 AH.
  69. Tirmidhi, Mohammad bin Isa, Sunan al-Tirmidhi, Edited and Explained by Shaker, Ahmed Mohammed, Cairo: Dar al-Hadith, 1419 AH.
  70. Wasiti Zabidi, Muhib al-Din, Taj al-Arus min Jawahir al-Qamus (The Crown of the Bride from the Jewels of the Dictionary), Beirut: Dar al-Fikr, 1414 AH.
  71. Zamakhshari, Mahmoud, Al-Kashshaf 'an Haqaiq Ghawamid al-Tanzil (The Unveiling of the Realities of the Subtleties of the Revelation), Beirut: Arab Book House, 1407 AH.

 

 

11- Pajooheshname Hadith Tatbighee
Volume 10, Issue 18
August 2023
Pages 167-198

Files

History

  • Receive Date: 17 February 2022
  • Revise Date: 05 June 2022
  • Accept Date: 25 July 2022

Share

How to cite

Statistics