Peer Review Process

 

  1. Receive an article from the Journal of Comparative Hadith Research site.
  2.   In the first stage, the article is identified through (Samimnoor.ir).
  3.  In case of non-similarity, the article is checked for compliance with the criteria, and if it lacks the basic criteria (full author details are not entered, authors' orchid code is not registered, commitment letter and non-conflict of interest form is not attached) Article will be returned to the author for completion.
  4. After the author completes the information, the associate editor reviews the article (at this stage, the expert secretary reviews the article based on the relevance of the article to the journal, the standards and priorities of the journal. Articles that do not meet these criteria will not be accepted.
  5.  If not approved, notify the responsible author no later than two weeks after submission
  6.  In case of initial approval by the associate editor, send a letter to the author to pay the arbitration fee
  7.  Initial payment by the author and resendSend the article to the evaluator
  8.  Submit referee correction suggestions, after evaluation to the responsible author or authors
  9. Submit article to final evaluator after correction
  10.  If the article is finally approved by the evaluators, the draft will be prepared at the editorial board meeting.
  11.  Final decision on accepting or not accepting articles in the editorial board meeting
  12. Notify the author to pay the final cost of publishing the article
  13. Deposit money and upload its receipt on the journal site
  14.  Send approved articles of each issue to the editor
  15. Submit edited articles to the voting page
  16.  Submit page layout articles to authors for final review and approval
  17.  Electronic publication of the article in the website.