Documentary Research and the Semantic Range of the Narration “Innama al-A’mal bi-al-Niyyat” (the base of the act is its intention) from the perspective of Two Major Islamic Sects

Document Type : Original Article

Authors

1 ssistant Professor, Department of Jurisprudence and Fundamentals of Law, Razavi University of Islamic Sciences

2 Associate Professor, Department of Jurisprudence and Fundamentals, Razavi University of Islamic Sciences

Abstract

The narration of “Innama al-A’mal bi-al-Niyyat” is a narration that Shia and Sunni jurists have used in various chapters of jurisprudence and have cited it in several issues. This narration is challenged and questioned in two dimensions; One is from chain of document and the other is from the point of view of content. Although many works have been written about these two dimensions, but less has been done to examine the document and explain its semantic scope in a comparative way and to determine the stronger meaning by citing evidences. This article aims to use a descriptive-analytical method, using a library method, while discussing and examining its documents from the perspective of Two Major Islamic Sects, to investigate its possibilities and semantic scope, and to determine the strongest possibility with the assistance of numerous clues and evidences. The findings of this research indicate that the narration is authentic and acceptable in terms of issuance as a document based on the school of issuance trustworthiness by combining evidences such as narrative reputation, practical reputation, agreement with authentic narrations, spiritual or abstract massive report. In terms of the content, which has many possibilities, the possibility that what is meant by it is a comprehensive concept and what the scholars have said as the meaning and meaning of the narration is an example of it, seems stronger.

Keywords

References

  1. The Holy Quran.
  2. Akhond Khorasani, Muhammad Kazem, Kefayat OlOsool, Qom, Al Olbeai Publosher, 1989.
  3. Amoli, Mirza Hashim, Al- Maalim Ol Mathoorat, Qom, Ilmiyyeh Publisher, 1990.
  4. Ibn Ami Yala, Muhammad Bin Muhammad, Tabaghat Ol Hanabilat, , Beirut, Dar Al Marifat, ----------- .
  5. Ibn Asir Gazi, Mubarak bin Muhammad, Al Nehayat, Qom, Ismailian Publishing Institute,------.
  6. Ibn Barraj Al Tarablosi, Muhammad Bin Hasan, Javahir Al Fighh, Qom, Islamic Publishing Office, 1991.
  7. Ibn Teimiyyat, Ahmad, The Fatava Cillection, Malic Fafad Comprihensive for Publishing, 1996.
  8. Ibn Hajar Asghalani, Ahmad bin Ali, Fath Olbari, Beirut, Dar Ol Marifat, 1977..
  9. Ibn Hajar Asghalani, Ahmad bin Ali, Nozhat Ol NAzar, , Beirut, Al Maktabat Ol Asriyyat, , 2009.
  10. Ibn Rajab, Abd Ol Rrahman, Jamia OL Oloom Va Lhikam Fi Sharh Khamsin Hadith, , Beirut, Dar Al Salam For Publishing, 2003.
  11. Ibn Rishd Andolosi, Muhammad Bin Ahmad, Bedayat Ol Mujtahid, , Beirut, Dar Alfikr , Beirut, Dar Alfikr, 1995.
  12. Ibn Zohtah, Hamzat Bin Ali, Ghoniyat Ol Nozooa, Qom, Imam Sadigh Institute,1997.
  13. Ibn Salah, Osman Bin Abd Olrahman,Marifat Anvaa Al Hadith, Beirut, Dar Olkotob Alelmiah, 2002.
  14. Ibn Abbad< Ismaeel, Al Mohit Bil Loghah, Beirut, Dar The Woeld of Book,1994.
  15. Ibn Faris, Ahmad Bin Zakaria, MujamMaghaees Al LOghat, Qom, Tablighat Islami Office Publisher,1984.
  16. Ibn Ghodamat, Abd Ol Lah, Al Mughnee, Eject, Cairo, The Cairo Publisher, 1968.
  17. Ibn Kasir, Ismaeel, Al Bahes Ol Hasis Ila Marifat El Hadith, Beirut, Dar Olkotob Alelmiah, ---.
  18. Ibn Majeh, Muhammad, Sonan Ibn Majeh, Research: Muhammad Foad, Beirut, Dar Ihyaa alkotob alelmiah, ---- .
  19. Ibn Manzoor, Muhammad Bin Mokram, Lisan Ol Arab, , Beirut, Dar Alfikr , Beirut, Dar Sadir, 1994.
  20. Ansaree, Mortaza, Kitab Ol Taharat, Qom, Al Ol Beiet Institute for Publishing, ---- .
  21. Irvanee, Muhammad Baghir, Al Halghat Ol Ssaniat fi Os loobeha Al ssani, , Beirut, The Adherent for Publoshing, ---- .
  22. Irvanee, Muhammad Baghir, Kefayat Ol Osool fi sobeha Al Ssani, Najaf, Ihya Al Toras Al Shiah institute, 2008.Bahranee, Yoofof, Al Dorar Ol Najafiat, Beirut, Dar Ol Mostafa Le Ihya Al Toras, 2002.
  23. Bahranee, Yoosof, al Dorar Al Najafiat, Beirut, Dar ol Mos tafa Le ihya Al torath, 2002.
  24. Bokharee, Muhammad Bin Ismaeel, Al Jame Al Mustand Al Shih, Damasks, Dar Tough Al Nejat, 2001.
  25. Besuoonee, Ahmad, Megazine of Al Vaay Al Islami “from Prophetic Revealation, innama Al Amal Bi Al Niyyat” 157, 2019.
  26. Bashiri, Hasan Hosein, Derasat Fighhieh – Naration of Innama Al Amal- Fighh ahlolbeit Megazine, 55, 2009.
  27. Jalalee Mazandaranee, Sayyed Mahmood, Al Mahsool fi Elm Al Asool,Qom, Imama sadigh Institute, 1994.
  28. Javaheree, Muhammad, Al Vazeh fi Sharh Al Orvat, Beirut, Al Aref for press, 2015.
  29. Jouharee, Ismaeel Bin Hammad, AlSehah Taj Ol Loghah, Beirut, Dar ol Ilm,1987.
  30. Hor Amelee, Muhammad Bin Hasan, Vasael Oshshiah, Qom, Al Ol Beit Institute, 1987
  31. Hakim, Seyyed Muhsen, Mustamsak Ol Orvat, Beirut, Dar Ehya Al Torath, Al Arabee,1959.
  32. Hellee, Ahmad Bin Muhammad, Al MUhazzab Ol Barea, Qom, Islamic Publishing Office, 1987.
  33. Hellee, Muhammad Bin Hasan, Al Resalat Ol Fakhriat, Mashhad, Islamic Discourse Assembally, 1991.
  34. Hellee, Hasan Bin Yoosof, Tazkerat Ol Foghaha, Qom, Al Ol Beit Institute,1994.
  35. Hellee, Hasan Bin Yoosof, kholasat Ol Aghval, qom, Jurisprudence Publishing Institute, 1997.
  36. Hellee, Hasan Bin Yoosof, Montaha Al Matlab, Mashhad, Islamic Discourse Assembally, 1995.
  37. Hellee, Jafar bin Hasan, Al Rasael Ol Tesa, qom, Ayat Ol Lah Marashee Library Press, 1996.
  38. Hellee, Jafar bin Hasan, Sharayea Ol Islam, Qom, Ismaeelian Institute, 1991.
  39. Hellee, Jafar bin Hasan, Al Mutabar Fi Sharh Al Mokhtasar, qom, Sayyed Al Shohada Institute, 1990.
  40. Khoee, Seyyed Abo Al Ghasem, Ajvad Ol Taghrirat, Qom, Mustafavee bookstore, 1989.
  41. Khoee, Seyyed Abo Al Ghasem, Mesbah Al Osool, Qom, al Davaree bookstore, 1995.
  42. Ragheb isfahanee, Hosein Bin Muhammad, Mofradat Alfaz Quran, Lebanan, Dar Ol elm, 1995.
  43. Ravandee, Saeed, Feghh Ol Quran, qom, Ayat Ol Lah Marashee Library Press,1985.
  44. Sabegh, Seyyed, Figh Ol Sonnat, Beirut, Dar Ol Kotob Al Arabiat, 1977.
  45. Saket, Taha Muhammad, “ Innama Al Aamal bi Al Niyyat” Al Azhar Megazine, 1, 1948.
  46. Saket, Taha Muhammad, “ AlSonan val Hokm Al Nabviyat” Al Hedayat ol Islamiat Megazine, 19, 1942.
  47. Sarakhsee, Muhammad, Al Mabsoot, Beirut, Dar ol Marefat, 1994.
  48. Safeeree,Muhammad Bin Omar, AlMajalis Ol Vaziyyat, Beirut, Dar Ol Marefat, 2004.
  49. Sayyed Murtaza Alam Ol Hoda, Ali Bin Hosein, Al Masael Ol Naseriat, Tehran, Cultural and Islamic Relations, 1997.
  50. Sayyed Murtaza Alam Ol Hoda, Ali Bin Hosein,Al Intesar, Qom, Islamic Publishing Office, 1995.
  51. Siuty, Jalal Ol Din, Tadrib Ol Rravi, Beirut, Dar ol Fikr, 2014.
  52. Siuty, Jalal Ol Din, Muntaha al Amal, Beirut, Dar Ibn Hazm, 1419
  53. Shoukanee, Muhammad Bin Ali, Neil Ol aotar, Beirut, Dar ol Jeil, 1973.
  54. Sobhee, Saleh, Oloom Ol Hadith Va Mustlahehe, Beirut, Dar ol Ilm, 1986.
  55. Sadr, Sayyed Muhammad Bagher, Droos Fi Elm El Osool, Beirut, Dar ol Koto Al Lobnanee, 1986.
  56. Sadoogh, Muhammad Bin Ali, Elal Oshsharea, Qom, Davaree Bookstore, 1967.
  57. Sadoogh, Muhammad Bin Ali, Al Hedayat Fi L Osool Val Forooa, qom, Imam Hadee Institute, 1998.
  58. Tabarsee, Fazl Bin Hasan, Al Mutalaf Min Al Mukhtalaf, Mashhad, Mashhad, Islamic Discourse Assembally, 1990.
  59. Toreihee, Fakhroddin, Majmaa Ol Bahrein, Qom, Al Mortaza Publisher, 1983.
  60. Toosee, Muhammad Bin Hasan, Al Amalee, Qom, Dar OSSaghafat, 1994.
  61. Toosee, Muhammad Bin Hasan, AlKhelaf, Qom, Islamic Publishing Office, 1987.
  62. Toosee, Muhammad Bin Hasan, Al Tahzeeb, Tehran, Dar Ol Kotob Al islmieh, 1987.
  63. Toosee, Khaje Nasir, Al Anvar Ol Jalaliat, Mashhad, Islamic Discourse Assembally, 2000.
  64. Amelee, Muhammad Bin Makkee, ( Shaheed, The First), Al Ghavaed Va Al Faveed, Qom, Mufeed Bookstore, ---- .
  65. Amelee, Muhammad Bin Makkee, ( Shaheed, The First), Zekra l Shiat, Qom< Al Olbeit Instutute,1999.
  66. Amelee, Zein Ol Din, ( Shahid The Second0, Al Reayat fi Elm AlDerayat, qom, Ayat Ol Lah Marashee Library Press, 1988.
  67. Abbasee Moghadam, Mostafa, et Al, “ A criticism into the Authenticity of tha Tradition of Innama Al Aulhg bi NNiyat” , Magazine of Oloom Hadith Comparative, 2019.
  68. Abd Ol Jabbar, Soheib, Al Mosnad Al Mouzooee, ----,
  69. Asimin, Muhammad Bin Saleh, Noor Ali AlDDarb Verdicts, ----, ---- .
  70. Araghee, Abd Orraheem, AlTagheed va Al Izah, Beirut, Dar ol Hadith, 1985.
  71. Oreizee, Ali Bin Jafar, Masael Ali Bin Jafar, Qom, Al Ol Beit Institute, 1989.
  72. Fazem Mighdad Seivaree, Meghdad Bin Abdollah, AlTangheea ol Raea, qom, Ayat Ol Lah Marashee Library Press, 1984.
  73. Faraheedi, Khalil bIn Ahmad, Kitab Ol Ein, Qom, Hijrat Publisher, 1992.
  74. Firooz Abadi, Muhammad bin Yaghoob, AlGhamoos Ol Muheet, Beirut, Al Resalat Institute, 2005.
  75. Feiz Kashanee, Muhammad Bin Muhsen, alShafee Fi Al Al Aghaeed, Tehran, Allouh Ol Mahfooz Publishing House, 2004.
  76. Feiz Kashanee, Muhammad Bin Muhsen, al Vafee, Isfahan, Imam Amir Ol Mumeneen Bookstore, 1986.
  77. Feivamee, ahmad Bin Ali, Al Misbah Ol Moneer, Beirut, Al Moneer Publisher,
  78. Ghastalanee, Ahmad bin Muhammad, Al Mavaheb Ol Daniyat…., Cuero, ATtofighiat Bookstore, --- .
  79. Ghosheiree Nishabooree, muslem Bin Hajjaj, Al Mosnad Alssahih, Beirut, Dar Iha Alttoras Al Arabee, ---.
  80. Koleinee, Muhammad Bin Yaghoob, Alkafee, Qom, Dar Olhadeeth for publishing, 2008.
  81. Gholshadee, Hadee, an investigation into the Naration of innama al Amal…, Rasekhoon Website,
  82. Mazandaranee, Muhammad Saleh, Sharh osool Kafee, Tehran, Al Islamiat Bookstore, 2003.
  83. Mujahed, Seyyed Muhammad, Mafateeh Ol Osool, Qom, Al Ol Beit Institute, 1879.
  84. Majlese, Muhammad Bagher, Bahar ol anvar, Beirut, Pres and Publishing Institute, 1990.
  85. Majlesee, Muhammad Taghee, Rouzat al Mottagheen, Qom, Islamic Cultural Institute, 1986.
  86. Majlesee, Muhammad Taghee, Lavame Sahebgharaee, qom, Ismaeelian, 1994.
  87. Muhammadee Reishahree, Muhammad, Mizan ol hekmat, qom, al Aalm Ol islamee bookstore, ----.
  88. Maghrebee, numan Bin Muhammad, Taveel oldaaem, ciero, al Marefat house, ---- .
  89. Mesbah Yazdee, Muhammad taghee, Aeen Parvaz, qom, Imam Khimeinee Research &Educational institute, 2013.
  90. Mustafavee, Hasan, A Research Into the terms Of The Quran, Tehran, Book Centre for Translation & Publishing, 1982.
  91. Mutahharee, Murtaza, adl elahee, Tehran, Sadra, 1982.
  92. Muzaffar, Muhammad Reza, Osool Ol Fighh, Qom, aalam Ol Islamee bookstore, --- .
  93. Mofeed, Muhammad bin Muhammad, Almasael ossaghaniat, Qom, Sheikh Mofeed Millennium international congress, 1993.
  94. Makarim Shirazee, Naser, Al Ghavaed Ol Fighhiat, Qom, Imam Ali Bin Abi taleb School1991.
  95. Moosavee Jazayeree, Seyyed Muhammad Jafar, Muntaha Al Darayat, Qom, Khayyam Publisher, 1983.
  96. Moosavee Khomeinee, Seyyed Rooh Ollah, Al Makasib ol Moharramat, Qom, The institute of Imam Khomeinee’works, 1995.
  97. Mirza Qomee, aboolghasim, Rasael Mirza, qom, Islamic Propagation Office, 2006.
  98. Najashee, Ahmad bin Ali, Rijal Nejashee, research: Moosa Shobeiree, qom, Islamic Press institute, ---.
  99. Najafee, Muhammad Hasan, Javahir olkalam, Beirut, Dar ihya Torath Al Arabeee, 1984.
  100. Nesaee, Ahmad Bin Shoeib, alssonsn Al Soghra, Halab, Islamic press Publisher, 1986.
  101. Noore Mirza Hosein, Mustadrak olVasael, Beirut, al Ol Beit institute, 1990.
  102. Navavi, Mohyee Al Din, Sharh Ol Arbaeen, ---, --- .
  103. Navavi, Mohyee Al Din, Al Majmooa Sharh ol Muhazzab, Beirut, Dar ol fikr,---- .
  104. Navavi, Mohyee Al Din, Al Menhaj, Beirut, Dar ihya Al Torath Al Arabee, 1972.
  105. https://khaandaniha.ir/news/646025
  106. https://www.noormags.ir/view/fa/articlepage/400336
  107. https://www.noormags.ir/view/fa/articlepage/507559
  108. https://www.noormags.ir/view/fa/articlepage/679125
11- Pajooheshname Hadith Tatbighee
Volume 9, Issue 17 - Serial Number 17
Year 9, No. 17, Fall and Winter 2023
March 2023
Pages 83-106

Files

History

  • Receive Date: 28 May 2021
  • Revise Date: 15 May 2022
  • Accept Date: 07 June 2022

Share

How to cite

Statistics