Criticism of the Arguments for the Ineffectiveness of the Rule of Presenting Hadith on the Quran

Document Type : Original Article

Authors

1 Associate Professor, Department of Quranic and Hadith Sciences, Razavi University of Islamic Sciences

2 MS, Quran and Hadith Sciences, Razavi University of Islamic Sciences, Mashhad, Iran

Abstract

 One of the methods of verifying the text of hadiths is to present them to the Holy Quran. This process, which is called “the rule of presenting hadiths to the Quran”, is based on various rational and narrative reasons. The most famous of these reasons are a group of traditions called “narrations of presenting”. Nevertheless, some objections have been raised to the correctness of this rule to the trend of Sunni and Shia appearance-centrism. The current research, using library sources and using the descriptive-analytical method seeks to reread these reasons, the extent of their meaning and answer to them. In this research, the problems of the opponents of the rule are divided into four categories: epistemological approaches, documentary problems, problems based on narrative evidence, and incorrect implications for the implementation of the presenting rule. In a general evaluation, the root of the aforementioned epistemological and content-based reasons goes back to issues such as understanding one side of some narrations, and lack of solid understanding of the concept of opposition in the context of wide-ranging narrations, and equating the concept of Sunnah with Hadith. The answers provided to the aforementioned problems are also based on the understanding of these issues. Documentary problems have also occurred due to focusing on a limited number of narrations presented, which are answered by referring to other hadiths and obtaining meaningful massiveness or abundance. The result is that none of the reasons can be used to harm the narration of presenting.

Keywords

References

  1.  

    1. the holy Qur’an, translated by Nasir  Makarim  Shirazi
    2. Ibn Atheer Jazari, Mubarak bin Muhammad, (1397), The End in Gharib Hadith and Athar, Qom, Ismailian Institution.
    3. Ibn Babawayh, Muhammad bin Ali, (1376), Al-Amali, Tehran, Kitabchi.
    4. ------------------, (1378), Eyes of Akhbar al-Ridha (peace be upon him), Tehran, Jahan Publishing.
    5. Ibn Hazm, Ali bin Ahmed, (1404), Al-Hakam fi Usul Al-Ahkam, Cairo, Dar Al-Hadith.
    6. Ibn Hanbal, Ahmad Ibn Muhammad, (1416), the Musnad of Imam Ahmad Ibn Hanbal, Beirut, first, Al-Resala Foundation.
    7. Ibn Tayfur, Ahmed bin Abi Taher, (1326), Balaghat al-Nisa’, Cairo, his father Abbas’ school printing house.
    8. Ibn Abd al-Barr, Youssef, (1414), collector of the statement of knowledge and its merit, Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, Dar Ibn al-Jawzi.
    9. Ibn Qutayba Dinori, Abdullah, (1419), Interpretation of Different Hadiths, Beirut, islamic Bureau.
    10. Ibn Majah, Muhammad bin Yazid, (1430), Sunan Ibn Majah, Shuaib Al-Arnaout, Beja, Dar Al-Resalah Al-Alameya.
    11. Ibn Mulqen, Omar bin Ali, (1994), The reminder of the needy for the hadiths of the curriculum, Hamdi Abdul Majeed Al-Salafi, Beirut, first, the Islamic library.
    12. Ibn Ashour, Muhammad Taher, (1420), the interpretation of liberation and enlightenment known as the interpretation of Ibn Ashour, Beirut, first, Foundation for Arab History.
    13. Ibn Atiyah, Abdel-Haq, (1422), the brief editor in the interpretation of the dear book, Beirut, Dar al-Kutub al-Ilmiyya.
    14. Abu Shuhba, Muhammad bin Muhammad, (1406), Defending the Sunnah and Refuting the Semi-Orientalists and Contemporary Writers, Cairo, Islamic Research Academy.
    15. Abi Dawood, Suleiman bin Ashath, (1430), Sunan Abi Dawood, Shoaib Al-Arnaout, Beirut, Dar Al-Resala Al-Alameya.
    16. Ahmadi Noorabadi, Mahdi, (1394), Exhibited by Hadith Barr Quran, Qom, Dar Al-Hadith, Dom. 17. Ahmadi Miangi, Ali, (1419), the writings of the Messenger, may God bless him and his family and grant them peace, Qom, Dar al-Hadith.
    17. Akhund Khorasani, Muhammad Kazem, (1393), "Kifayat al-Osoul", Qom, Chaharm, Dar al-Fikr. 19. Esther Abadi, Muhammad Amin bin Muhammad Sharif, (1426), Civil Benefits (Makki Evidence in Refutations of Arguments of Civil Fictions, Investigator of Mercy of God Mercy Araki, Qom, Islamic Publication Institution.
    18. Isfahani, Mirza Mahdi, (1388), the letters of Shanakht Quran, Tehran, Munir.
    19. Al-Bani, Muhammad Nasir al-Din, (1412), a series of weak and fabricated hadiths and their bad impact on the nation, Riyadhl, Dar al-Ma’arif.
    20. Ansari, Mortada (1424), Faraed Al-Osoul, Qom, Najm, Islamic Thought Council.
    21. Bahrani, Youssef bin Ahmed, (1363), The Fresh Gardens in the Provisions of the Immaculate Progeny, Investigator Muhammad Taqi Irani, Qom, Islamic Publication Institution.
    22. Barqi, Ahmed bin Muhammad bin Khaled, (1371), Al-Mahasin, Qom, Dar Al-Kutub Al-Islamiyyah.
    23. Behbehani, Muhammad Baqer, (1426), Hashiyah al-Wafi, Qom, Foundation of Allama al-Mujaddid.
    24. Bayhaqi, Ahmed bin Hussein, (1408), Evidence of Prophecy and Knowledge of the Conditions of the Author of Sharia , Abd al- Muti Qalaji , Beirut , Dar al-Kutub al-Ilmiyya.
    25. Bayhaqi, Ahmed bin Hussein, (1405), The Book of Reading behind the Imam, Muhammad Al-Saeed bin Bassiouni Zaghloul, Beirut, Dar Al-Kutub Al-Ilmiyya.
    26. Bayhaqi, Ahmed bin Hussein, (1412), Knowledge of Sunan and Archeology, Abdul Muti Amin Qalaji, Karachi, University of Islamic Studies.
    27. Tamassoki Bidgooli, Ali, (1398), “The Hadith of Orang; Bazkhwani, the hadith of his sofa with a document and his life Khaandan Sunnat.” Investigations of the Sciences of the Qur’an and Hadith, Sal 16, Shamara 3, Bayez, pp. 1-28.
    28. Joozi, Abdullah bin Youssef, (1424), Editing of Hadith Sciences, Beirut, Al-Rayyan Institution for Printing, Publishing and Distribution.
    29. Jazairi, Nimatullah, (1387), The Source of Life, the Authenticity of the Mujtahid’s Saying from the Dead, Qom, Farhangi Tibian Foundation.
    30. Jazairi, Nimatullah, (1430), Nur al-Barahin or Anis al-Wahid in Sharh al-Tawheed, Investigator: Seyyed Mahdi Rajaei, Qom, Dom, Institution of Islamic Publishing.
    31. Jassas, Ahmed bin Ali, (1405), Provisions of the Qur’an, Beirut, House of Revival of Arab Heritage.
    32. Hakim Nishapuri, Muhammad bin Abdullah, (1411), Al-Mustadrak on the Two Sahihs, Mustafa Abdul Qadir Atta, Beirut, Dar Al-Kutub Al-Ilmiyya.
    33. Hurr Amili, Muhammad bin Hassan, (1403), Al-Fawad Al-Tusi, Qom, Scientific Press.
    34. Hurr Amili, Muhammad bin Hassan, (1418), The Important Chapters on the Origins of the Imams, Qom , Ma’arif Islamic Institution, Imam Reza (pbuh).
    35. Hurr Amili, Muhammad bin Hassan, (1409), Wasa’il Al-Shi’a, Qom, Awal, Aal al-Bayt Institute.
    36. Haskany, Obaidullah bin Abdullah, (1411), Evidence of Downloading the Rules of Preference, Tehran, Awal, Zarat Farhang and Islamic Guidance.
    37. Khatib Baghdadi, Ahmed bin Ali, (BTA), Enough in the Science of Narration, Abu Abdullah Surki, Madinah, Scientific Library.
    38. Khatib, Moataz, (2011), Refuting the hadith from the side of the text, a study in the curricula of modernists and fundamentalists, Beirut, Awal, The Arabic Network for Research and Publishing.
    39. Khoei, Abul-Qasim, (1389), The Statement in the Interpretation of the Qur’an, Tehran, Khorasandy.
    40. Daraqtni, Ali bin Omar, (1386), Sunan al-Daraqutni, Beirut, Dar al-Ma'rifa.
    41. Darmi, Abdullah bin Abdul-Rahman, (1407), Sunan Al-Darmi, Fawaz Ahmed Zumrli, Beirut, first, Dar Al-Kitab Al-Arabi.
    42. Demini, Misfer Azmallah, (1404), Standards of Criticism of Maton al-Sunnah, Riyadh, Awal, Peja. 45. Dahabi, Muhammad Husayn, (1397), Tafsir wa Al-Mufsiroon, Beirut, Arab Heritage Revival House.
    43. ​​Radwan, Omar bin Ibrahim, (1413), Orientalist views on the Holy Qur’an and its interpretation, Riyadh, First, Dar Taiba.
    44. The General Presidency of the Departments of Scholarly Research, Ifta, Call and Guidance, Journal of Islamic Research, Naram Afzar, Comprehensive Library, Department of Mosques, Journals, and the like.
    45. Zarqani, Muhammad Abd al-Azim, (BTA), Sources of Gratitude in the Sciences of the Qur’an, Beirut, First, House of Revival of Arab Heritage.
    46. Zarkashi, Muhammad bin Bahader, (1421), The Ocean of the Ocean in Usul al-Fiqh, Beirut, Dar al-Kutub al-Ilmiyya.
    47. Zamakhshari, Mahmoud bin Omar, (1407), the revealer of the facts of the mysteries of downloading and the eyes of gossip in the faces of interpretation, Beirut, Som, Dar Al-Kitab Al-Arabi. 51. Sibai, Mustafa, (1402), The Sunnah and Its Place in Islamic Legislation, Damascus, Somme, Islamic Office
    48. Sobhani, Jaafar, (1439), the hadith of the Prophet between the narration and the knowledge, Qom, Som, Foundation of Imam Sadiq (peace be upon him).
    49. Sobhani, Jaafar, (1415), Al-Majsul fi Ilm Al-Usul, Qom, Imam Sadiq (pbuh) Foundation.
    50. Sarakhsi, Muhammad bin Ahmed, (1414), Osoul al-Sarakhsi, Beirut, Awal, Dar al-Kutub al-Ilmiyya.
    51. Samani, Mansour bin Muhammad, (1419), Cutters of Evidence in the Fundamentals of Jurisprudence, Riyadh, Awal, Library of Repentance.
    52. Sayed Najm, Abdel Moneim, (1399), “Codification of the Sunnah and its Status”, Islamic University of Madinah, Sal Yazdhom, Shamara Som, Rabi’ Al-Awal.
    53. Shashi, Ahmed bin Muhammad, (1402), The Origins of Al-Shashi, Beirut, Dar Al-Kitab Al-Arabi.
    54. Shatby, Ibrahim bin Musa, (1417), Al-Muwafaqat, Hassan Al Salman, Riyadh, Awal, Ibn Affan House.
    55. Shafi’i, Muhammad Ibn Idris, (2001), Differences in Hadith, Rifaat Fawzy, Mansoura, Egypt, first, Dar Al-Wafa.
    56. Shafi'i, Muhammad bin Idris, (1410), Al-Umm, Beirut, Dar Al-Marefa.
    57. Shafi’i, Muhammad ibn Idris, (1422), the message, Rifaat Fawzy, Mansoura, Egypt, first, Dar Al-Wafa.
    58. Sharif Al-Radi, Muhammad Bin Hussein, (1422), The Metaphors of the Prophet, Qom, First, Dar Al-Hadith.
    59. Shanqeeti, Muhammad Amin, (1427), Adwa’ al-Bayan fi clarifying the Qur’an with the Qur’an, Beirut, Dar al-Kutub al-Ilmiyya.
    60. Shawkani, Muhammad bin Ali, (1419), Irshad Al-Foul, Ahmed Ezzo Inaya, Beirut, first, Dar Al-Kitab Al-Arabi.
    61. Shirazi, Sadiq, (1436), Statement of Origins, Qom, Dom, Dar Al-Ansar.
    62. Sadeghi Tehrani, Muhammad, (1405), Al-Furqan in Interpreting the Qur’an with the Qur’an and the Sunnah, Tehran, Islamic Farhang.
    63. Salhi, Fatimah and Hamkaran, (1398), “Barasi Theoretical Evidence for the Specialization of Khattab Hai Qur’an with Infallible Persons,” Pjhohnameh Tafsir wa Zaban Qur’an, Saal Hashtam, Shamara Panzdham, Payez and Zamistan, pp. 45-62.
    64. Saghani, Hassan bin Muhammad, (1405), Subjects, Najm Abdul Rahman Khalaf, Damascus, Dar Al-Mamoun Heritage.
    65. Saffar, Muhammad bin Hassan, (1404), Baseer Al-Darat, Qom, Dom, Library of Ayatollah Marashi Najafi.
    66. Tabatabai, Muhammad Husayn, (1391), The Qur’an Dar Islam, Qom, Banzadhum, Islamic publications book.
    67. Tabatabai, Muhammad Husayn, (1390), The Balance in the Interpretation of the Qur’an, Beirut, Al-Alame Institute for Publications.
    68. Tabarani, Suleiman bin Ahmed, (2008 AD), Al-Tafsir Al-Kabeer, Jordan, Dar Al-Kitab Al-Thaqafi. 73. Tabarsi, Fadl bin Hassan, (1372), Majma` al-Bayan fi Tafsir al-Qur’an, Tehran, Nasir Khusraw.
    69. Tabari, Muhammad bin Jarir, (1421), Jami’ al-Bayan fi Tafsir al-Qur’an (Tafsir al-Tabari), Lebanon, first, Dar al-Ma’rifa.
    70. Tosi, Muhammad bin Hassan, (1431), The Clarification in the Interpretation of the Qur’an, Qom, Dhul Qirbi.
    71. Tosi, Muhammad bin Hassan, (1417), Al-Iddah fi Usul Fiqh, Muhammad Reda Ansari.
    72. Amili, Jaafar Mortada, (1415), correct from the biography of the greatest prophet, Beirut, Dar Al-Hadi, Chaharm.
    73. Abdel-Khaleq, Abdel-Ghani, (2000), Hajji Al-Sunnah, Beirut, Dar Al-Wafa.
    74. Dear Kiya, Gholamali, (1388), “Didgah’s criticisms contradict the presentation of the hadith of righteousness of the Qur’an”, Ma’arafat Publishing, Farvardin, Shamara 136, pp. 85-98.
    75. Askari, Murtada, (1374), The Noble Qur’an and the Narrations of the Two Schools, Qom, Awal, Daneshgah Usul Deen.
    76. Akbari (Sheikh Mufid), Muhammad bin Muhammad, (1413), Correction of the Imami Beliefs, Qom, First, The World Conference of the Mufid Sheikh.
    77. Ghazali, Muhammad bin Muhammad, (1413), al-Mustafa, Muhammad Abd al-Salam, Beirut, first, Dar al-Kutub al-Ilmiyya.
    78. Fassi, Muhammad bin Hassan, (1416), the lofty thought in the history of Islamic jurisprudence, Beirut, Dar al-Kutub al-Ilmiyya.
    79. Fayd Kashani, Muhammad Mohsen, (1415), Tafsir Al-Safi, Tehran, Chap: Doom, his library.
    80. Qurtubi, Muhammad bin Ahmed, (1364), The Collector of the provisions of the Qur’an, Tehran, first, Nasir Khusraw.
    81. Kazmi, Muhammad Ali, (1404), The Benefits of the Fundamentals (Report of the lesson of Ayatollah Nayini), Qom, Modarres University.
    82. Kulayni, Muhammad bin Yaqoub, (1429), al-Kafi, Qom, Dar al-Hadith. 88. Mamqani, Muhammad Reza, (1413), Mustadrakat Miqbas Al-Hidaya, Qom, Mehr.
    83. Mottaki Hindi, Ali Bin Hussam Al-Din, (1401), Kanz Al-Amal fi Sunan al-Sayyal wa’l-Ala’, Beirut, Najm, Al-Resalah Institute.
    84. Majlesi, Muhammad Baqer, (1403), Bihar Al-Anwar, Beirut, Arab Heritage Revival House.
    85. Majlesi, Muhammad Baqir, (1404), Mirror of the Minds in Explanation of the News of the Prophet’s Family, Tehran, Dom, Dar al-Kutub al-Islamiyyah.
    86. Majlesi, Muhammad Taqi, (1406), Rawdat Al-Mutaqin fi Sharh Whoever does not attend the Faqih, Qom, Chap: Doom, Islamic Foundation of Koshanpur.
    87. Mazeed, Ali Abdel-Basit, (PTA), the curriculum of the modernists in the first century AH until the present time, Cairo, The Egyptian General Book Authority.
    88. Maarif, Muhammad Hadi, (1429), Introduction to the Sciences of the Qur’an, Qom, Dom, Introduction.
    89. Makarim Shirazi, Nasser, (1390), Encyclopedia of Comparative Islamic Jurisprudence, Qom, Awal, Imam Ali bin Abi Talib Publishing House.
    90. Mousavi Khomeini, Ruhollah, (1368), Al-Rasa’il, Qom, Som, Ismailian.
    91. Mirdamad, Muhammad Baqir, (1311), Al-Rawashah Al-Sama’ah fi Sharh Imami Hadiths, Qom, Awal, House of the Caliphate.
    92. Nasa’i, Ahmed, (1410), Tafsir Al-Nisa’i, Beirut, First, Cultural Books Foundation.
    93. Norouzi, Mojtaba and Hamkaran, (1393), “Parsi Didgah is in conflict with the hadiths of Dar Ahl As-Sunnat”, Bulletin of Qur’an and Hadith Sciences, Shamara 92, Bahar and Tabistan.
    94. Hashemi Khoei, Mirza Habibullah, (1400), Minhaj al-Baraa’ah, Tehran, Chaharm, Islamic Library. 101. Hashemi Shahroudi, Mahmoud, (1433), Researches in the Science of Usul, Muhammed Baqir Sadr Lesson Reports, Qom, Foundation of Jurisprudence and Knowledge of Ahl al-Bayt (pbuh).
    95. Yazdi, Muhammad Kazem, (1433), The Book of Contradictions, Qom, Dom, Madyan.
11- Pajooheshname Hadith Tatbighee
Volume 9, Issue 16
September 2022
Pages 225-248

Files

History

  • Receive Date: 02 March 2021
  • Revise Date: 12 October 2021
  • Accept Date: 31 October 2021

Share

How to cite

Statistics