The Validation of the Interpretive Narrations of the Tow Major Sects of Islam about the Faith of Abu Talib

Document Type : Original Article

Authors

1 Assistant Professor, Department of Jurisprudence and Fundamentals of Islamic Law, Razavi University, Mashhad, Iran

2 Associate Professor, Department of Jurisprudence and Fundamentals of Islamic Law, Razavi University of Islamic Sciences, Mashhad, Iran

Abstract

One of the ways to correctly understand the history of Islam and the influential figures of the early days of Islam is to analyze the narrations about them. Hazrat Abu Talib was one of the personalities of this period, about whom many traditions have been reported. Two different views have been raised about him: a group of people, citing some hadiths about three verses of the Holy Quran, have thought that he died without faith. Another group believes that these narrations cannot be a reliable witness to this idea. Now the question about him is whether he believed in the Prophet of Islam and died with faith? The following article examines these narrations using library sources and in a descriptive-analytical method, and by stating their fundamental problems, such as weak documentation, denotation, conflict with other narrations, incompatibility with the contents and context of the verses, etc., their invalidity will be proved and by referring to massively reported narrations, the consensus of the Ahl al-Bayt, the consensus of Imamiyyah, the explicit poems of Abu Talib, and considering the criterion of discerning the truth, considered his faith as one of the unquestionable facts of the history of Islam.
 

Keywords

References

  1. The Holy Quran
  2. Nahjol Balaghah, 1990.
  3. Aboo Rayyeh, Mahmood, Illustration into the Muhammad Traditions, Qom, Ansarian Institut, 1999.
  4. Aboo Zareh, Ahmad, almodallisin book, Beirut, Dar Olvafa,1994.
  5. Abootalib, Abd Manaf , Abootalib Poetry Book, Compiler: Aboo Heghan Mehrazi, Beirut, Vafa Institut, 2003.
  6. Albanee, ArvaOlghalil, Beirut,Islamic Scool, 1985.
  7. Aloosee, Sayyid Mahmood, Rooholmaani fee Tafsir AlQuran, Qum, Hoda Publisher,2001.
  8. Amini, Abdol Hosein, Abootalib Faith and his Biography,…, …., ….,
  9. ---------,--------------, AlGhadir, Beirut, Dar Olkotob Alarabee, 1977.
  10. Baghavi, Hosein, Maalim Oltanzil, Beirut,Dar Ihyae Altoras Alarabee, 1999.
  11. Baghdadee, Alaoldin, khazanat Ol Adab, Beirut, Dar olmarefat, ---.
  12. Baghdadee, khalid, Tashih Olgharaat Fi Nahjolbalaghah, Qom, Alaghanedieh Studying Cfntre, 2006.
  13. Baghdadee, Khatib, Baghdad Histiry, Beirut, Dar Olkotob Alelmiah,1996.
  14. -------------, -------, Baghdad History, Beirut, Dar algharb Alislamee,2001.
  15. Balazaree, AhmadJomalon min Ansab AlAshraf, Beirut, Dar olfikr1996.
  16. Beihaghee, Ahmad, Dalael mOnnobovat…, Beirut, Dar Olkotob Al elmiah, 1985.
  17. Beizavee, ahmad, Anvar olttanzil,ed. 1, Beirut,Dar Ihyae altoras,1997.
  18. Bokharee, Muhammad, Aljamia Olmosnad, Research: Muhammad Zoheir,cairo, Dar Oltough, 2001.
  19. Fakhr razee, Muhammad Bin Omar, Mafatih Algheib, Beirut,Dar Ihyae altoras,1999.
  20. Fakir Meibodee. Muhammad,” A critic study of isnad and concept of Quranic Verses interpreted on Abootalib, Quranic Theology, 14, spring and Summer , 2021.
  21. Fatal Neishabooree,Muhammad, Rouzat Alvaezin, Qom, Dalil MA,2002.
  22. Fazl Ollah, Muhammad Hosein, Min Vahy El Quran, Beirut, Dar Al mOllak,1998.
  23. Feiz Kashanee, Muhammad, Tafsir alSafee, AlMahajjat Olbeiza, Qom, Jameeh Mudarresin Poblisher,1996.
  24. ----------------,--------, Tafsir Alssafee, Tehran, maktabat Alsadr, 1994.
  25. Ghazee, Inayat, Asbab AlNozoolo, Beirut, Dar Olkotob Al elmiah,---- .
  26. Ghortobee, Muhammad bin Ahmad,Aljami Leahkam AlQuran, Beirut,Dar Ihyae altoras,1985.
  27. Ghosheiree Neishabooree, Muslim bin Hajjaj,Almosnad Alssahih, Beirut,Dar Ihyae altoras,--- .
  28. Haghee Broosavee, Ismaeel, Rooh Olbayan In Quranic Interpretation, Beirut, Dar Olfikr, ---.
  29. Hakim Neishbooree, Muhammad, al Mustadrak, Beirut, Dar Olkotob Al-Elmiah,1991.
  30. Halabee, borhan olddin, alKashf Olhasis…, Beirut, aalam Olkotob, 1987.
  31. Hellee, Hasan Bin Yoosof, Mabadee Al Vossol.., Qom, Elmieh Publisher, 1984.
  32. ----, ------------, Nagjolhagh…, qom, Dar olhijrat, 1994.
  33. Hor Ameli, Muhammad Bin Hasan, Vasail AlShia, Beirut, Dar Alfikr, 1987.
  34. Ibn Abd Olbir, Jouzif, AlEstiab, Beirut, Dar Oljeil, 1992.
  35. Ibn Abi AlHadid, Abd ol Hamid, Nahjol Balagha Illustration, Beirut, Dar Ihyaa alkotob alelmiah,
  36. ---- , ab dol hamid, Sharh Nahjol Balagheh, Beirut, Darol Kotob Al Elmiah, 2002.
  37. Ibn Ashoor, Muhammad, Altahrir Comentary, Beirut, Arabic History institute,.
  38. Ibn Atiieh, abd olhagh, Almoharrar Olvajiz, Beirut, Dar Olelmiaa, 2002.
  39. Ibn Habban, Muhammad, Althighat, India, Alothmani Encyclopeadia, 1973.
  40. Ibn Hajar Asghalani, Ahmad bin Ali, Al Ethabat, Beirut, Dar olkotob Alelmieh, 1994.
  41. ----, ------, Fath Olbari, Beirut, Dar Olmarifat, 1977.
  42. Ibn Hanbal, Ahmad, Mosnad Ibn Hanbal, Beirut, Dar Sadir, ---.
  43. Ibn Ishagh, Muhammad, Biography of the Prophet, Beirut, Dar olfikr Publisher, 2020.
  44. ----, ------, Ibn Ishagh Biography, Beirut, Dar olfikr, 1978.
  45. Ibn Jezzi, Muhamad bin Ahmad, Research: Abdollah Khalid, Attashil leoloom alttanzig, Beirut, Dar Olargham, 1995.
  46. Ibn Jouzi, Abdolrahman, Almouzooat, Beirut, Dar Olfikr, 1983.
  47. -------, --------, Zad olmasir fi elm eltafsir, Beirut, Dar Olfikr, 1987.
  48. Ibn Kasir, Ismaeel, The Ptophetic Biograpty, Beirut, Dar Ihya Alttoras, 1966.
  49. Ibn Khalifah, Alavi, Jami Olnoghool, Cairo, 1984.
  50. Ibn Saad, Muhammad, Altabaghat Olkoba, Beirut, Dar Olkotob Al elmiah
  51. Ibn Saad, Muhammad, Altabaghat Olkoba, Beirut, Dar Sadir, 1968.
  52. Ibn Soleiman, Mughatel, Ibn soleiman Comentry, Lebanan, Dar Olkotob Al elmiah, 2003.
  53. Ibn Tavoos, sayyid Razi, Attaraif, Qom, Khayyam, 1980.
  54. Ibrahim Hasan, Hasan, Political History of Islam, Tran. Aboolghasim Payandeh, Javip Publisher,1995.
  55. Jaghmaee, Habeeb, A Research and Translation of Tabaree Interpretation, Tehran, Toos Publisher,1978.
  56. Karajakee, Muhammad, Kanz Alfavaed,-----, ----, 1950.
  57. Khazin, ala Olddin, Labab Olttavil fi Maaa=ni Altanzil, Beirut, Dar Olkotob Al-Elmiah, 1995.
  58. Koleinee, Muhammad Bin Yaghoob,AlKafee,Tehran, Dar Alkotob AlIslamieh, 1987.
  59. Majlesee, Muhammad Bagher,Bahar alanvar, Beirut, alvafa Institute, 1983.
  60. Makarim Shirazee, Nasir, Nemooneh Comentry,Tehran, Dar Alkotob AlIslamieh,1993.
  61. Manavee, Muhammad Abd Alorraoof, Feiz Alghadir, Beirut, Dar Olkotob Al-Elmiah,1994.
  62. Meibodee, Rashid Alddin,Kashf AlAsrar,Tehran, Amir Kabir Publisher, 1952.
  63. Mofid, Muhammad Bi Numan, The faith Of Abootalib,Qom, Besat Institute,----.
  64. Moghatel Bin Solaeiman, AlMoghatel Comentary, Beirut, Dar Olkotob Al-Elmiah,2003.
  65. Moosavee, Faghghar bin Maad,The Faith of Aboo Talib,qom, Sayyid AlShohada, 1990.
  66. Naraghee, Abolghasim,Shab Almaghal,Qom, alIslamee publishing Institute,2001.
  67. Navavee, Yahjaa bin Sharaf, Alminhaj9 Illustration of Sahih Muslim0, Beirut,Dar Ihyae Altoras, 1972.
  68. Nisaee,Ahmad bin Shoeib,Alsonan AlKobra, Beirut, Dar Olkotob Al-Elmiah,1991.
  69. Qomee, Abbas, Safinat olbahar,Mashhad, Majmaa Albohoos Alislamieh, 2010.
  70. Qumee, Abolghasim,Alghavaneen AlMuhakkameh,qom, Ehya AlKotob AlIslamieh, 2009.
  71. Razee, Aboolfotoh Hosein Bin Alee, Rouz ol Janan va Rooh olbayan, Tehran, islamieh Bookshop, 1978   .
  72. Sadoogh, Muhammad Bin Ali, Kamal Alddin va tamam Alnemat, Tehran, Islamiah Poblisher,2017.
  73. -----, --------, Maanee Al Akhbar, Qom, Islamic Publisher Office,1983.
  74. Sayyid Murtaza, Ali Bin Hosein, Alzariah ila Osool Alshariah, Tehran, Tehran University Press,1998.
  75. Siootee, Jalal Alddin, Alddor Al Mansoor, Beirut,Dar Ihyae altoras,1984.
  76. ------, --------, AlItghan fi Oloom Al Quran, ----, Razee Publisher, ----.
  77. Siootee, Jalal Alddin, AlJalalin Comentary, Beirut, AlNoor institute for Publishing,1995.
  78. -----, ----, Alkholafa History, Beirut, Matoogh ekhvan Press, ----.
  79. -------, ----------, Labab Alnoghool fi Asbab Alnozool, Beirut, dar Alhijrat,
  80. Sobhanee, Jafar, The history of Froogh Abadiaat,Qom, Boostan Kitab, 1965.
  81. Sobhee, salih, Mabahis fi Oloom Alquran, Qom, Dar Ol Kotob AlIslamieh,1985.
  82. Tabaranee, Solaeiman,Almujam AlSaghir, Beirut, Dar Olkotob Alarabee, 1984.
  83. Tabaranee, Solaeiman,AlMujam Ol Ovsat, Ejept, Dar olharamein For poblishing, 1994.
  84. Tabaree, Muhammad bin Jarir, Jamia Al Bayan, Beirut, -----,
  85. Tabarsee, Fazl Bin Hasan, Majma Albayan for Interpretation of the Quran, Tehran, Nasir Khosrow poblisher, 1992.
  86. Tabatabaee, Sayyid Muhammad Hosein, Almizan fi Tafseer AlQuran,Qom, Islamic Publisher Office, 1996.
  87. Termazee, Muhammad, Termazee Traditions, ed.3, Beirut, Dar Olfikr, 1983.
  88. Thaalibi, Abdorrahman, Javhir olhesan fi Tafsir al Quran, Beirut,Dar Ihyae altoras,1998.
  89. Thalabee, ahmad, Alkashf Va AlBayan In quranic Interpretation, Beirut,Dar Ihyae altoras,2001.
  90. Thouree, sofyan, sofyan souree, interpretation, Beirut, Dar olelmiah, 1983.
  91. Toosee, Muhammad Bin Hasan, Altibyan fi Tafsir AlQuran, Beirut,Dar Ihyae altoras, ----.
  92. Vahedee, Ali Bin Ahmad,Asbab AlNozool, Beirut, Dar Olkotob Al elmiah, ---.
  93. Yaghoobee, Ahmad Bin Ishagh, The History of Yaghoobee, Beirut, Dar Sadir,---.,
  94. Zahabee, Muhammad Bin Ahmad, History of islam, ---, Almaktabat ol Tofogheah, 2003.
  95. -----------, ---------, Mizan ol Iatedal, Dar Olmarifat,2001.
  96. Zamakhsharee, Jar Olllah, Alkashshaf, Beirut, Dar Olkotob Alarabee,
  97. Zarkolee, Borhan olddin, AlIlam, Beirut, Dar Olilm lilmalaen,----.
  98. Zeinee Dahlan, Ahmad, asna Almatalib fi Nejat Abitalib, Jordan, Dar Al Imam AlNavavee,
11- Pajooheshname Hadith Tatbighee
Volume 9, Issue 16
September 2022
Pages 89-112

Files

History

  • Receive Date: 28 July 2021
  • Revise Date: 21 March 2022
  • Accept Date: 09 May 2022

Share

How to cite

Statistics