Critical review of the sources of the book "Jafariyat / Ash'athiyat"

Document Type : Original Article

Authors

1 1 PhD of Quranic and Hadith Sciences, University of Tehran (Responsible Author):

2 M. A. student of Quran and Hadith, University of Tehran

Abstract

Abstract
The book of Ja'fariyat, also known as Ash'athiyat, was popularized in Egypt by Ibn Ash'ath at the beginning of the fourth century. This book contains more than 1600 hadiths, most of which have been narrated through Imam Kadhim (AS) from Imam Sadegh (AS) quoting their fathers. The uniform attribution of this large volume of hadiths faces several problems, some of which are discussed in this article. The troubles in Jafaryat's book have risen the question of what sources did the author use? In this article, by examining various evidences and sampling and similarity of narrations, it has been shown that in compiling the book, the author has used sources such as: the book of Ismail Ibn Abiziad Sakuni and the heritage of the general narrators of Medina. By carefully documenting each hadith, it is possible to identify cases of Sakuni with high probability.

Keywords


1 Holy Quran
2 Ajori Baghdadi, Muhammad Ibn Al-Hosein, Zamm Al-Lavat, Editor:  
   Al-Sayed Ibrahim, Majdi, Maktab Al-Quran, Cairo, “n.d.”
3 Ibn Abi Shaybah, Abdullah Ibn Muhammad, Al-Musannaf, Editor: Al-jomma,   
   Hamad Ibn Abdullah and Al-Luhaidan, Muhammad Ibn Ibrahim, Dar Al-Roshd,    
   Riyadh, First Edition, 1425 AH
4 Ibn Abi Assem, Ahmed Ibn Amro, Al-Ahaad and Al-Mathani, Editor: Al-
   Jawabera, Basem Feisal Ahmed, Dar Al-Raya - Riyadh, First Edition, 1411 AH
5 Ibn Athir, Mubarak Ibn Muhammad Jazri, Alnahaya Fi Gharib Al Hadith and
   Al Athar, Editor: Tanahi, Mahmoud Muhammad, Moassese Matbooati Ismailian,
   Qom, 1367 SH
6 Ibn Araabi, Ahmed Ibn Muhammad Al-Basri, Mu’jam Ibn al-Araabi, Editor:
   Al-Hoseini, Abd Al-Muhsin Ibn Ibrahim, Dar Ibn Al-Jawzi, Saudi Arabia, First
   Edition, 1418 AH
7 Ibn Babuyah, Muhammad Ibn Ali, Savab Al-Amaal and Eghab Al-Amaal, Dar 
   Al-Sharif Al-Radhi for Publishing, Qom, Second Edition, 1406 AH
8 Ibn Babuyah, Muhammad Ibn Ali, Al-Khisal, Editor: Ghaffari, Ali Akbar,
    Jame’e Modarresin, Qom, First Edition, 1362 SH
9 Ibn Babuyah, Muhammad Ibn Ali, Elal Al-Sharaa’e, Daavari Bookstore, Qom,
   First Edition, 1385 SH
10 Ibn Babuyah, Muhammad Ibn Ali, Man La Yahzarah Al-Faqih, Editor:
     Ghafari, Ali Akbar, Daftar Entesharat Islami Vabaste Be Jame’e Modarresin
     Hoze Elmiye Qom, Qom, Second Edition, 1413 AH
11 Ibn Jaad, Ali Ibn Al-Jaad Ibn Ubaid al-Johari al-Baghdadi, Musnad Ibn al-Jaad,
     Editor: Amer Ahmed Haidar, Moassese Nader - Beirut, First Edition,
     1410 AH
12 Ibn Haban, Abu hatim Muhammad Al-Tamimi Al-Daremi, Sahih Ibn Haban,
     respectively, Ibn Balban, Editor: Shuaib Al-Arnaoot, Moassese Resala-Beirut,
     second edition, 1993-1414, 1414 AH
13 Ibn Hazm, Ali Ibn Ahmed Al-Andalusi, Al-Mahali Bel-Asaar, Dar Al-Fikr-   
     Beirut, “n.d.”
14 Ibn Hamid, Abu Hamid Abd Al-Hamid Ibn Hamid Ibn Nasr Al-Kassi, Al-
     montakhab Men Masnad Abd Ibn Hamid, Editor: Al-Adwi, Mustafa, Dar
     bel Nassiya for Publishing and Distribution, Second Edition, 1423 AH
15 Ibn Hayon, Neman Ibn Muhammad Maghribi, Daa’im Al-Islam, Editor:
     Feidhi, Asif, Moassese Aal Al-Bayt, peace be upon him, Qom, Second
     Edition, 1385 AH
16 Ibn Sa’ad, Muhammad Ibn Sa’ad Al-Zahri, Dar Ahya Al-Torab Al-Arabi,
     Beirut, First Edition, 1417 AH
17 Ibn Tavoos, Ali Ibn Musa, Al-Tarae’f Fi Ma’refa Mazahib Al-Tavae’f,
     Editor: Ashour, Ali, Khayam, Qom, 1400 Ah
18 Ibn Tavoos, Ali Ibn Musa, Jamal Al-Osbo’ Bekamal Al-Amal Al-Mashro’,
     Dar Al-Radhi, Qom, 1330 AH
19 Ibn Abd Al-Bar, Abu Omar Yusef Ibn Abdullah, Al-Estizkar, Editor: Atta,
     Salim Muhammad and Mu’aviz, Muhammad Ali, Dar Al-Kitab Al-E’lmiyah,
     Beirut, first edition, 1421 AH
20 Ibn Iraq, Ali Ibn Muhammad Al-Kanani, Tanzih Al-Shari’a Al-Marfoo’a An 
     Al-Akhbar Al-Shani’a Al-Mozooa’, Editor: Abd Al-Vahab Abd Al-Latif and
     Al-Ghamaari, Abdullah Muhammad Al-Seddiq, Dar Al-Kutub Al-E’lmiya 
     Beirut, first edition, 1399 AH
21 Ibn Asakir, Ali Ibn Hassan Al-Damishqi, The History of Damascus,
     Editor: Al-A’mroui, Omar Ibn Gharaama, Dar Al-Fikr, Beirut, First Edition,
     1415 AH
22 Ibn Fares, Ahmed, Ma’jam Maqayes Al-logha, Editor: Haroon, Abd
     Al-Salam Muhammad, Maktab Al-E’lam Al Islami, Qom, 1404 AH
23 Ibn Qisrani, Abu Al-Fadhl Muhammad Ibn Tahir Al Moqadasi, Zakhira al-
     Hefaz, Editor: Al-Fariwaei, Abd Al-Rahman, Dar Al-Salaf - Riyadh, First
     Edition, 1416 AH
24 Ibn Maaja, Muhammad Ibn Yazid Al Qazwini, Sunan Ibn Maajah, Editor:
    Al-Arnaout, Shuaib, Dar Al-Resala Al-Alamiya, First Edition, 1430 AH
25 Ibn Maed, Fakhaar Al-Musavi, Iman Abi-Talib Al-Ma’rouf Be Al-Hojja Ala 
     Al-Dhahib Ela Kofr Abi Talib, Editor: Bahr Al-Uloom, Muhammad, Dar
     Sayed Al-Shuhada, For Publishing, Qom, First Edition, 1410 AH
26 Ibn Molqan, Abu Hafs Umar Ibn Ali, Al-Tozih le Sharh Al-Jame’ Al-Sahih,
     Editor: Dar Al-Falah le Al-Bahs Al-E’lmi and Tahqiq Al-Toras, Dar Al-
     Navader, Damascus - Syria, First Edition, 1429 AH
27 Abu Davood, Sulaiman Ibn Al-Asha’th Al-Sajistani, Al-Sunan, Editor Al-
     Arnaout, Shuaib, Dar Al-Resala Al-Alamia, first edition, 1430 AH
28  Abu Davood, Sulaiman Ibn Al-Asha’th Al-Sajistani, Al-Marasil, Editor:
      Shuaib Al-Arnaout, Moassese Al-Resala, Beirut, First Edition, 1408 AH
29 Abu A’vana, Yaqoub Ibn Ishaq, Mostakhrej Abi Avana, Editor: Al-
     Damishqi, Ayman Ibn Aref Al-Damishqi, Dar Al-Ma’refa - Beirut, first edition,
     1419 AH
30 Abu Lehya, Nour Al-Din, Ahkam Al-Talaq and Al-faskh and Asarehima Be Ro’ya
     Maqasediya, Dar Al-Anwar for Publishing and Distribution, Second
     Edition, 1436 AH
31 Abu Muti’ Al Mesri, Muhammad Ibn Abd Al-Vahed, Al-Aval Men Amali Abi
     Muti’ Al-Mesri (Makhtota Be Al-Maktaba Al-Dhaheriya)
32 Abu Naeim, Ahmed Ibn Abdullah Al-Asbahani, Helyat Al-O’liya and Tabaqat
     Al-Asfiya, Maktab Al-Saada, Egypt, 1394 AH
33 Abu Naeim, Ahmed Ibn Abdullah Al-Asbahani, Ma’refat Al Sahaba,
     Editor: Al-Azazi, Adel Ibn Yusif, Dar Al-Vatan For Publishing,
     Riyadh, First Edition, 1419 AH
34 Ahmed Ibn Hanbal, Abu Abdullah Al-Shaybani, Al-E’lal and Ma’refa Al-Rejal,
      Editor: Vasi Allah Ibn Muhammad Abbas, Dar Al-Khani, Riyadh, Second
      Edition, 1422 BC
35. Ahmed Ibn Hanbal, Abu Abdullah Al-Shaybani, Al Musnad, Editor: Al-
      Arnaout, Shuaib and Murshid, Adil, Moassese Al-Resalah, First Edition,      
36 Bahrani, Yusif Ibn Ahmed, Al-Hadaeq Al-Nadhera Fi Ahkam Al-E’trat Al-
     Tahera, Editor: Irawani, Muhammad Taqi, Moassese Al-Nashr Al-Islamiya,
     Qom, “n.d.”
37 Bukhari, Muhammad Ibn Ismaeil, Al-Adab Al-Mofrad, Editor: Abd Al-Baqi,
     Muhammad Fuad, Dar Al-Bashae’r Al-Islamiya-Beirut, Third Edition,1409 AH
38 Bukhari, Muhammad Ibn Ismaeil, Al-Jame Al-Musnad Al-Sahih Al-Mokhtasar
     Men Omoor Rasool Allah, peace be upon him, Editor: Al-Naser,
     Muhammad Zuhair Ibn Nasser, Dar Touq Al-Najat, First Edition, 1422 AH
39 Burqi, Ahmed Ibn Muhammad Ibn Khalid, Al-Mahasen, Editor: Muhadith, Jalal Al-din, Dar Al-Kutub Al-Islamiya, Qom, Second Edition, 1371 AH
40 Baghdadi, Khatib Ahmed Ibn Ali Ibn Sabet, Editor: Al-Ma’rouf, Bashar
     A’vad, Dar Al-Mufrab Al-Islami, First Edition, 1422 AH
41 Bazaar, Abu Bakr Ahmed Ibn Amro, Musnad Al-Bazaar Al-manshoor Basem
     Al-Bahr Al-Zakhar, Editor: Mahfouz Al-Rahman Zain Allah, Maktab Al-
     O’loom And Al-Hokm- Medina, First Edition, 2009 AD
42. Belazari, Ahmed Ibn Yahya, Jamal Men Ansab Al-Ashraf, Editor: Zakaar,
      Suhail and Al-Zarkali, Riyadh, Dar Al-Fikr, Beirut, First Edition, 1417 AH
43 Belazari, Ahmed Ibn Yahya, Fotoh Al-Baldan, Dar and Maktab Al Hilal,
     Beirut, 1988 AD
44 Boosiri, Ahmed Ibn Abi Bakr, Athaaf Al-Khayra Al-Mohra Bezavae’d Al-
     Masanid Al-E’shra, Editor: Dar Al-Mishkat Le Al-Bahs Al-E’lmi, Dar Al-
     Vatan for Publishing, Riyadh, First Edition, 1420 AH
45 Beyhaqi, Ahmed Ibn al Hosein Ibn Ali, Dalae’l Al-Nobova and Ma’refa Ahval
     Sahib Al-shari’a, Dar Al-Kutub Al-E’lmiya - Beirut, First Edition, 1405 AH
46 Beyhaqi, Ahmed Ibn Al Hosein Ibn Ali, Al-Sunan Al-Saghir, Editor:
     Qala’ji, Abdul Mua’tti Amin, Jame’a Al-Derasat Al-Islamiya, Karachi-
      Pakistan, First Edition, 1410 AH
47 Beyhaqi, Ahmed Ibn al Hosein Ibn Ali, Al-Sunan Al-Kobra, A’tta, Muhammad
     Abd Al-Qadir, Dar Al-Kotob Al-E’lmiya, Beirut, Third Edition, 1424 AH
48 Tarmadhi, Muhammad Ibn Issa, Sunan Al-Tarmadhi, Editor: Shakir,
     Ahmed Muhammad and Abd Al-Baqi, Muhammad Fuad, Mustafa Al-Babi Al-
     Halabi- Egypt, second edition, 1395 AH
49 Al-Toubli Al-Bahrani, Sayed Hashim Ibn Sulaiman, Al-Borhan fi Tafsir Al-
     Quran, Editor: Qesm Al-Derasaat Al-Islamiya Moassese Al-Be’sa, Moassese
      Be’sa, Qom, First Edition, 1374 AH
50. Jorjani, Abu Ahmed Ibn O’dai, Al-Kaamil Fi Zo’afa Al-Rejal, Editor: Abd Al-
      Mojood, Adil Ahmed and Mo’avedh, Ali Muhammad, Dar Al-Kitab Al-
      E’lmiya, Beirut, 1418 AH
51 Jasaas, Ahmed Ibn Ali Al-Razi, Ahkaam Al-Quran, Dar Al-Kutub Al-E’lmiya, Beirut,
     First Edition, 1415 AH
52 Harith Ibn Muhammad Al-Tamimi, Baghya Al-Bahes An Zava’ed Mosnad Al-harith,
     Al-montaqi: Ali Ibn Abi Bakr Al-Heysami, Editor: Dr. Hosein Ahmed Salih Al-
     Bakeri, Markaz Khedma Al-sona and Al-Sira Al-Nabaviya, Al-Madina Al-Monavara,
     First Edition, 1413
53 Horre A’meli, Muhammad Ibn Hasan, Tafsil Vasa’el Al-Shi’a Ela Tahsil Masa’el Al-
     Shari’a, Moassese Aal Al-bait,Qom, 1409 AH
54 Helli, Hasan Ibn Yusif Ibn Mutahar, Muntaha Al-Matlab Fi Tahqiq Al-Madhhab,
     Majma’ Al-Bohoos Al-Islamiya, First Edition, 1412 AH
55 Helli, Hasan Ibn Yusif Ibn Mutahar, Nahj Al-Haq and Kashf Al-Sidgh, Dar Al-Kitab
     Al-Lebanon, Beirut, 1982 SH
56 Hamidi, Abdullah Ibn Zubair, Al-Musnad, Editor: Al-Darani, Hasan Salim, Dar
     Al-Saqaa, Damascus, First Edition, 1996 SH
57 Khaza’ei Marwzi, Nae’im Ibn Hammad, Al-Fatn, Editor: Al-Zahiri, Samir Amin,
     Maktab Al-Tohid, Cairo, First Edition, 1412 AH
58 Khale’i, Abul Hasan Ali Ibn Al-Hassan, Al-Favae’d Al-Montagh Al-Hesan Al-Sahah
     and Al-Gharaeb Al-Mashhoor Be Al-khale’iyat, Revaya Abi Muhammad Abdullah
     Ibn Refaa’a Ibn Ghadeer Al-Sa’di, Takhrij Ahmed Ibn Al-Hassan Ibn Al-Hosein Al-
     Shirazi, Tashih: Ahmed Al-Khedhri
59 Daarqatni, Ali Ibn Omar, Al-Sunan, Dar Al-Fikr, Beirut, First Edition, 1418 AH
60 Daaremi, Abdullah Ibn Abdul Rahman, Al-Musnad Al-Daremi Al-Ma’rouf Be Sunan
     Al-Daaremi, Editor: Al-Daaraani, Hosein Salim, Dar Al-Mughni, The Saudi
     Arabia Kingdom, First Edition, 1412 AH
61 Al-Daani, Othman Ibn Saeed, Al-Sonan Al-Vareda Fi Al-Fotan And Ghava’eleha And
     Al-Sa’at And Ashrateha, Editor: Dr. Reza Allah Ibn Muhammad Idris Al-
     Mubarakfouri, Dar Al-Aa’simah - Riyadh, First Edition, 1416 AH
62 Derayati, Mustafa, Fehrestegan, Noskhehaye Khatti Iran (Fankha), Sazeman Asnaad
     And Kitabkhane Melli Iran, Tehran, 1390 SH
63 Dhahabi, Shams Al-Din Muhammad Ibn Ahmed, Mizan Al-E’tedal Fi Naqd Al-Rejal,    
     Editor: Al-Bajawi, Ali Muhammad, Dar Al-Ma’refa for Printing and Publishing,
     Beirut - Lebanon, First Edition, 1382 AH
64 Rab’i Ibn Habib, Dar Al-Saqafa Al-Diniya, Egypt, first edition, “n.d.”
65 Raavandi Kashaani, Fadhl Allah Ibn Ali, Al-Nawader, Editor: Sadiqi Ardistani,
     Ahmed, Dar Al-Kitab, Qom, Second Edition, “n.d.”
66 Zamakhshari, Mahmoud Ibn Omar, Asas Al-Balaghah, Dar Saader, Beirut, 1979 AD
67 Zamakhshari, Mahmoud Ibn Omar, Al-Fae’q Fi Gharib Al-Hadith, Editor: Shams Al-
     Din, Ibrahim, Dar Al-Kitab Al-E’lmiya, Beirut, 1417 AH
68 Zhiyan, Fatima, Arzyabi Bi E’tebari Asha’siyat, Pajooheshname Imamiye, Year
     1396 SH, Number 6.
69 Sajestani, Abu Bakr Ibn Abi Davood, Musnad A’isha, Editor: Hosein, Abdul
     Ghafoor Abdul Haq, Maktab Al-Aqsa, Kuwait, first edition, 1405 AH
70 Sarakhasi, Shams Al-Ae’mme Muhammad Ibn Ahmed, Al-Mabsut, Dar Al-Ma’refa-
     Beirut, 1414 AH
71 Al-Sori Ibn Yahya, Al-Shaibani Al-Mahlami, Ahadith Al-Sori Ibn Yahya (Makhtoot Noshr Fi
     Barnamaj Javami’ Al-Kelam Al-Majani Al-Tabe’ Al-Moqe’ Al-Shabake Al-Islamiya), First
     Edition, 2004 AD
72 Saeed Ibn Mansour, Abu Othman Al-Khurasani, Al-Sunan, Editor: Al-A’zami, Habib Al-
     Rahman, Al-Dar Al-Salafiya HInd, First Edition, 1403 AH
73 Salafi, Abu Taher Ahmed Ibn Muhammad, Editor: Ma’ali, Yahya Ma’ali and Al-Hassan,
     Abbas Sakhar, Maktab Azvaa Al-Salaf , Riyadh, first edition, 1425 AH
74 Salim Ibn Qais Hilali, Kitab Salim Ibn Qais Hilali, Editor: Ansari Zanjani Khoei’ni,
      Muhammad, Al-Hadi, Qom, 1405 AH
75 Samarqandi, Abu Al-Leys Nasr Ibn Muhammad, Tanbih Al-Ghafelin Be Ahadith Sayed Al-
     Anbiya and Al-Morsalin, Editor: Badivi, Yusif Ali, Dar Ibn Kathir, Damascus - Beirut, third
     edition, 1421 AH
76 Shaafe’i, Muhammad ­Ibn Idris, Al-Om, Dar Al-M’arefa, Beirut, 1410 AH
77 Shoberi Zanjani, Moosa, Kitab Nikah, Author: Yazdi, Muhammad Kazim Ibn Abd Al-
     Aziz, Moassese Pajooheshi Ra’y Pardaz, Qom, “n.d.”
78 Shushtari, Muhammad Taqi, Qamoos Al-Rejal, Jama’a Al-Modarersin Fi Al-Hoza Al-
     E’lmiya Be Qom, Moassese Al-Nash Al-Islami, 12 volumes, second edition, 1410 AH
79 Shokaani, Muhammad Ibn Ali, Al-Favae’d Al-Majmoo’a Fi Al-Ahadith Al-Modhoo’a,
     Editor: Al-Mo’alemi Al-Yamaani, Abd Al-Rahman Ibn Yahya, Dar Al-Kutub Al-
     E’lmiya, Beirut, Lebanon, “n.d.”
80 Sheiban Ibn Farookh, Part VI of the hadith of Sheiban Ibn Farookh and others (makhtota Be
     Al-Maktaba Al-Dhaheriya), Editor: Qesm Al-Makhtotat Besherka Ofoq Le Al-Barmajiyat,
     Sherka Ofoq Le Al-Barmajiyat, First Edition
81 Saffar, Muhammad Ibn Hassan, Bassa’er Al-Darajat Fi Fadha’el Al Muhammad, Peace    
      be upon him, Qom, Maktab Ayatollah Al-Mara’shi Al-Najafi, Second Edition, 1404 AH
82 Al-Sana’ni, Abd Al-Razaq Ibn Hamam, Musanaf Abd Al- Razaq, Beirut, Al-Maktab Al-
     Islami, Second Edition, 1390: 1403 AH -1970: 1983 AD
83 Tabarani, Sulaiman Ibn Ahmed, Al-Ava’el, Editor: Muhammad Shakur Bin Mahmoud
     Al-Haji Amerir, Moassese Resala, Dar Al-Furqan - Beirut, First Edition, 1403 AH
84 Tabarani, Sulaiman Ibn Ahmed, Musnad Al-Shaamiyyin, Editor:Al-Salafi, Hamdi Ibn
     Abd Al-Majid, Moassese Resala-Beirut, First Edition, 1405 AH
85 Tabarani, Sulaiman Ibn Ahmed, Al-Ma’jam Al-Kabir, Editor: Al-Salafi, Hamdi Ibn
     Abd Al-Majid, Cairo, Maktaba Ibn Timiya, 1415 AH
86 Tabarani, Sulaiman Ibn Ahmed, Al-Mo’jam Al-Awsat, Editor: Taariq Ibn Avaz Allah,
     Cairo, Dar Al-Haramin, first edition, “n.d.”
87 Tabarani, Sulaiman Ibn Ahmed, Al-Mo’jam Al-Saghir, Beirut, Al-Maktab Al-Islami; Oman,
     Dar Ammar, first edition, 1405 AH - 1985 AD
88 Tabari, Muhammad Ibn Jarir, Taarikh Al-Omam and Molook, Beirut, Dar Al-Turath, 1387
     AH
89 Tabari Amoli, Muhammad Ibn Jarir Ibn Rostam, Al-Mostarshad Fi Al-Imama, Qom,
     Kushanpoor, 1415 AH
90 Toosi, Muhammad Ibn Hasan, Al-Istibsar, Editor: Khersan, Hasan, Dar Al-Kotob Al-Islami,       
    Tehran, First Edition, 1390 AH
91 Toosi, Muhammad Ibn Hassan, Tahdhib Al-Ahkam, Dar Al-Kotob Al-Islamiya,
     Tehran, 1365 SH
92 Toosi, Muhammad Ibn Hassan, Al-Khalaaf, Moassese Al-Nashr Al-Islami, “n.d.”
93 Toosi, Muhammad Ibn Hassan, Rejal, Qom, Entesharat Islami Jame’e Modaresin,
     1415 AH
94 Toosi, Muhammad Ibn Hassan, Fehrest Kotob Al-Shi’a and Osoolehim and Asmae’
     Al-Mosnefin and Ashab Al-Osool, Editor: Tabatabai, Abd Al-Aziz, Maktab Al-
     Mohaqiq Al-Tabatabai, Qom, First Edition, 1420 AH
95 Al-Tayalesi, Abu Davood Sulaiman Ibn Davood, Musnad Abi Davood Al-Tayalesi,
      Egypt, Hajr for printing, publishing and distribution, First Edition, 1420 AH
96 A’dni, Muhammad Ibn Yahya, Al-Iman, Editor: Al-Jaaberi Al-Harbi, Hamad Ibn
      Hamdi, Al-Dar Al-Salafiya–Al-Kuwait, First Edition, 1407 AH
97 A’ffan Ibn Muslim Al-Saffar, Ahadith Affan Ibn Muslim, Editor: Hamza
     Ahmed Al-Zain, Dar Al-Hadith, Cairo, First Edition, 2004 SH
98 Fatni, Muhammad Taher Ibn Ali Al-Seddiqi Al-Hindi, Tadhkera Al-Mozo’at, Idara
     Al-Tab’a Al-Muniriya, First Edition, 1343 AH
99 Qasim Ibn Salam, Abu Ubayd Al-Heravi, Gharib Al-Hadith, Editor: Abd Al-
      Mua’yed Khan, Muhammad, Matba’at Dae’ra Al-Ma’aref Al-O’smaniya,
      Heydarabad Dakan, First Edition, 1384 AH
100 Qasim Ibn Salam, Abu Ubaid Al-Heravi, Fazae’l Al-Quran, Editor: Al-Attiyah,
       Marvan and Kharaba, Mahas and Taghi Al-Din, Vafa, Dar Ibn Kathir,
       Damascus, First Edition, 1415 AH
101 Qasim Ibn Salam, Abu Ubaid Al-Heravi, Al-Nasekh and Al-Mansookh, Editor:
       Al-Modaifer, Muhammad Ibn Saleh, Maktaba Al-Roshd, Riyadh, Second Edition,  
       1418 AH
102 Qirvani, Abdullah Ibn Abd Al-Rahman Al-Nafzi, Al-Navader and Al-Ziadaat Ala  
       Ma Fi Al-Modavana Men Ghaireha Men Al-Omehat, Editor: Al-Helou, Abd Al-
       Fattah Muhammad and Haji, Muhammad, Dar Al-Gharb Al-Islami, Beirut, First
       Edition, 1999 AD
103 Kitab “Al-Tabikh Fi Al-Maghrib and Al-Andolos Fi Asr Al-Movahedin Lemoallef
       Majhool, Ambrosio Uithi Miranda; Al-A’hd Al-Mesri (Al-Derasat Al-Islamiya
       Madrid) Year 1380 - Number 9 and 10
104 Cordoosh, Abu Ali Al-Hasan Ibn Ali Ibn Nasr Al-Toosi, Mokhtasar Al-Ahkam
       (Mostakhraj Al-Toosi Ala Jame’ Al-Tarmedhi, Editor: Al-Andonosi, Anis Ibn
       Ahmed Ibn Taher, Maktab Al-Ghuraba Al- Asariya- Al-Madina Al-Monavara, First
       Edition, 1415 AH
105 Koleini, Muhammad Ibn Yaqub, Al-Kafi, Dar Al-Kotob Al-Islamiya, Tehran, 1407
      AH
106 Malik Ibn Anas, Al-Muwata’, Editor: Abd Al-Baaqi, Muhammad Fouad, Dar Ahya Al-Torath Al-Arabi, Beirut, 1406 AH
107 Majlesi, Muhammad Baqir, Bahar Al-Anwar, Ahya Al-Torath Al-Arabi, Beirut,
       Second Edition, 1403 AH
108. Majlesi, Muhammad Baqir, Maladh Al-Akyar Fi Fahm Tahdhib Al-Akhbar, Editor:
        Rajae’i, Mahdi, KetabKhane Ayatollah Mara’shi Najafi, Qom, First Edition, 1406
        AH
109 Madadi, Sayed Ahmed: 1385, Doroos Kharij Feqh, session 22, Published
       on the author's website at the following link: 
       http://www.ostadmadadi.ir/persian/lesson/9505/
110 Madadi, Sayed Ahmed: 1388, Doroos Kharij Feqh, session 112, Published
       on the author's website at the following link: 
       http://www.ostadmadadi.ir/persian/lesson/9088/
111 Al-Murtaza, Seaed Ali Ibn Hosein Ibn Moosa, Al-Intesar Fi Inferadat Al-Imamiya, 
       “n.d.”
112 Marvzi, Muhammad Ibn Nasr Ibn Al-Hajaj, Ta’zim qadr Al-Salaat, Editor: Al-
      Farivae’i, Abd Al-Rahman Abd Al-Jabbar, Maktab Al-Dar –Al-Madina Al-
      Monavara, First Edition, 1406 AH
113 Mozzi, Yusif Ibn Abd Al-Rahman, Tahdhib Al-Kamal Fi Asma’ Al-Rejal, Editor:
       Ma’rouf, Bashar A’vad, Moassese Resala-Beirut, First Edition, 1400 AH
114 Masoudi, Ali Ibn Hosein, Moravej Al-Zahab and Ma'aden Al Johar, Editor: Dagher,
      Yusif As’ad, Dar Al-Hijra, Qom, 1409 AH
115 Muslim Ibn Al-Hajaj, Abu Al-Hassan Al-Qashiri Al-Nisaboori, Al-Musnad Al-Sahih
       Al-Mokhtasar Be Naghl Al-A’dl An Al-A’dl Ela Rasool Allah, Peace Be Upon Him,
       Editor: Muhammad Fuad Abd Al-Baqi, Dar Ahya Al-Torath Al-Arabi–Beirut, “n.d.”
116 Mo’amar Ibn Rashed, Abu Amr Al-Basari Al-Azdi, Al-Jame’, Editor: Al-A’zami, Habib
       Al-Rahman, Al-Majlis Al-E’lmi, Pakistan, Second Edition, 1403 AH
117 Moqadasi, Zia Al-Din Muhammad Ibn Abd Al-Vaahid, Al-Ahadith Al-Mokhtara or Al-
       Mostakhraj Men Al-Ahadith Al-Mokhtara Memma Lam Yakhrojho Al-Bokhari and Muslim
       Fi Sahihihima, Editor: Abd Al-Malik Ibn Abdullah Ibn Dahish, Dar Khezr for Printing,  
       Publishing and Distribution, Beirut - Lebanon, Third Edition, 1420 AH
118 Najashi, Ahmed Ibn Ali, Rajal Al-Najashy, Moassese Al-Nashr Al-Islami, Qom, Sixth
       Edition, 1365 SH
119 Najafi, Muhammad Hassan Ibn Baqir, Jawahir Al-Kalam Fi Sharh Shara’e Al-Islam,
       Editor: Qoochani, A’ba, Dar Ahya Al-Torath Al-Arabi, Beirut, Seventh Edition, 1981 AD
120 Nahaas, Abu Jafar Ahmed Ibn Muhammad, Al-Nasekh and Al-Mansookh, Editor:
       Muhammad Abd Al-Salam Muhammad, Maktab Al-Fallah- Kuwait, First Edition, 1408 AH
121 Nasae’i, Ahmed Ibn Shuaib, Al-Sunan Al-Kobra, Editor: Shalbi, Hassan Abd Al-Mon’am,
       Moassese Resala-Beirut, First Edition, 1421 AH
122 Nouri, Hosein Ibn Muhammad Taqi, Mustadrak Al-Vasa’el and Mostanbat Al-Masa’el,
       Moassese Aal Al-Bayt, peace be upon Him, Qom, 1408 AH
123 Nishaboori, Abu Abdullah Al-Hakim Muhammad Ibn Abdullah, Al-Mustadrak Ala Al-
       Sahihin, Editor: Mustafa Abd Al-Qader Atta, Dar Al-Kotob Al-E’lmiya - Beirut, First   
       Edition, 1411 AH
124 Vaahedi, Abol Hasan Ali Ibn Ahmed, Al-Vasit Fi Tafsir Al-Quran Al-Majid, Editor:
       Abd Al-Mojood, Adel Ahmed, Dar Al-Kotob Al-E’lmiya, Beirut - Lebanon, First Edition,
       1415 AH
125 Yahya Ibn Adam, Al-Kharaaj, Maktab Al-Torath, Egypt, First Edition, “n.d.”
 
Volume 7, Issue 13 - Serial Number 13
Journal of Comparative Hadith Sciences, Autumn and Winter 2021, 7(13), P:9-22
March 2021
Pages 201-242
  • Receive Date: 14 July 2020
  • Revise Date: 08 January 2021
  • Accept Date: 23 January 2021